MDacne vs. Proactiv. Which Acne Treatment Works Best?

A comparison between MDacne, ProactivMD, and Proactiv Plus for treating acne

What's the best acne treatment system available? We looked into the differences between the leading medical-grade acne treatment programs on the market today, MDacne's Customized Acne Treatment and two Proactiv lines, Proactiv MD, and Proactiv Plus. Looking for effective, medical-grade acne products available over-the-counter? Let's take a look at how these three systems compare! 

When was the classic Proactiv acne treatment kit developed?

Before diving into the newer Proactiv treatments, let's take a look at the history behind their products. The Proactiv kit was first launched its kit in the late ’80s (nearly three decades ago!) It was one of the first complete acne treatment kits available over-the-counter. Despite being a one-size-fits-all, this simple 3-step system has helped thousands manage their acne breakouts and get clear skin. In recent years, both Proactiv and other skincare companies have developed new treatments and technologies to help provide even more effective acne management. 

What is ProactivMD

ProactivMD uses low concentration adapalene 0.1% as the main active ingredient replacing the sulfur/benzoyl peroxide combination that is used in the standard Proactiv kit. The ProactivMD kit also includes a non-medicated cleanser and a moisturizer containing with SPF 30, which is necessary for sun protection as the active ingredientadapalene gel increases the skin's sensitivity to the sun. The Proactiv company warns users that ProactivMD may contain hydrochloric acid to adjust PH.

What is Proactiv Plus? 

Proactive Plus (Proactiv+) uses a combination of benzoyl peroxide with glycolic acid. The Proactiv+ kit also includes a medicated cleanser with benzoyl peroxide 2.5% and exfoliating beads as well as a medicated moisturizer with salicylic acid 0.5%. This combination is very potent and may be effective for some but is likely to be too strong for many 

How is MDacne different than ProactivMD and Proactiv Plus?

MDacne's customized acne treatment kit and the MDacne app

There are several differences between MDacne and the Proactiv lines. The most significant difference is that MDacne acne kits are personalized to each user as opposed to the one-size-fits-all solution. This is done through the MDacne app, which scans and analyzes a user's skin to determine their skin type, acne severity, and other measurements to determine which anti-acne medications their skin needs. 

MDacne uses micronized forms of benzoyl peroxide and/or salicylic acid (depending on the user), which penetrate the skin more easily, helping to clear acne more effectively with less irritation than traditional formulations with larger particles. They also include plant-based, natural ingredients (such as witch hazel and vitamin C) to help reduce skin redness, enhance the skin's natural healing process, and fade post-acne dark spots. This customization allows MDacne to treat a wide range of people with acne-prone skin to from those with sensitive skin to stubborn, severe acne with fewer side effects

Another key difference between MDacne and Proactiv are the services in the MDacne app. MDacne users have access to unlimited chat support with a dermatologist to guide them through their treatment and free fine-tuning of their ingredients as needed based on how their skin progresses for best results until clear skin is achieved.

Features

MDacne

Proactiv+

Proactiv MD

Medicated Cleanser

Customized
medicated cleanser 

One-size-fits-all medicated cleanser

One-size-fits-all
non-medicated cleanser

Active anti-acne medications

Multiple variations of  acne medications customized to the user skin type and acne severity

Benzoyl peroxide 2.5%

Adapalene 0.1%

(Highly irritating, sun sensitivity, not recommend in pregnancy)

Oil-free moisturizer

Yes

Yes

Yes

Skin analysis and ongoing monitoring

Yes

No

No

Dermatologist support

Yes (Free, unlimited)

No

No

Free fine-tuning of products

Yes

No

No

Vegan, Cruelty-free

Yes, PETA approved

N/A

N/A

Contains Hydrochloric acid

No

N/A

Yes

The takeaway

While all three of these treatments kits can be valuable to acne sufferers, MDacne's customized treatments are more likely to produce results with less irritation when compared to ProactivMD and Proactiv Plus. The personalization of the MDacne products using a combination of unique, cutting-edge medical formulations working synergistically with plant-based ingredients allows MDacne to provide superior acne treatment. Plus, with ongoing chat support from a board-certified dermatologist and free fine-tuning of the products, it' a service comparable if not superior to in-office dermatologist visits. 

To find the right acne treatments for your unique skin, take the free MDacne skin assessment by clicking here.

Image callout a241bc2c444052a21bcf2d0fcf2fd6f51bf11cca934998fba0b65ce7035d6a5b

Start your journey
to clear skin

  • Custom acne treatment cream, cleanser and moisturizer
  • Unlimited Dermatologist support
  • Ongoing skin monitoring
  • Free Shipping